Briefing: Federalist Papers 41-50
Main Themes:
Necessity and Scope of Federal Power: This section of the Federalist Papers focuses heavily on justifying the powers granted to the federal government under the proposed Constitution. The authors argue that these powers are essential for national security, domestic harmony, and effective governance.
Relationship Between Federal and State Governments: A key concern addressed is the balance of power between the federal and state governments. Madison and Hamilton reassure readers that the Constitution aims to strengthen the Union without undermining the legitimate roles of individual states.
Safeguards Against Tyranny: Recognizing concerns about potential abuses of power, the authors dedicate considerable space to outlining the checks and balances embedded in the Constitution to prevent any one branch of government from becoming too powerful.
Most Important Ideas and Facts:
Federalist 41:
Madison establishes the framework for evaluating the Constitution, emphasizing the need to assess the necessity of the powers granted to the federal government.
He categorizes the powers into six classes, with a focus on security against foreign danger (declaring war, raising armies, etc.) as a primary objective of the Union.
Madison defends the indefinite power to raise troops, arguing that it is essential for national defense and that limitations would be impractical and potentially dangerous.
He highlights the danger of standing armies in peacetime but stresses that a united America is less likely to require a large military establishment.
Federalist 42:
Madison continues his analysis of federal powers, focusing on the regulation of foreign affairs (treaties, ambassadors, etc.) and commerce (including the controversial issue of slave trade).
He justifies the Constitution's improvements over the Articles of Confederation, emphasizing the need for clear and comprehensive powers to avoid "gradual and unobserved usurpations of power."
Madison addresses the compromise on the slave trade, framing it as a step towards eventual abolition while acknowledging the political realities of the time.
He emphasizes the importance of the regulation of interstate commerce, arguing it is crucial for preventing conflicts and economic exploitation between states.
Federalist 43:
This paper explores the remaining "miscellaneous powers" granted to the federal government, such as promoting science and arts (patents and copyrights), governing federal territories, defining treason, and admitting new states.
Madison defends the "necessary and proper" clause, arguing it is essential for providing the government with the means to execute its enumerated powers.
He stresses the importance of federal control over federal districts and territories, ensuring the government's independence and security.
The paper examines the guaranty clause, which mandates a republican form of government for all states, as a protection against anti-republican movements or foreign interference.
Federalist 44:
Madison shifts focus to the restrictions imposed on the states, highlighting the need for such limitations to ensure the effectiveness of the federal government and prevent abuses by individual states.
He defends the prohibitions against state treaties, coining money, issuing bills of credit, and enacting laws that impair the obligation of contracts. These restrictions are deemed crucial for national unity, economic stability, and individual rights.
The paper underscores the importance of federal supremacy by asserting that the Constitution and federal laws "shall be the supreme law of the land". This principle aims to prevent conflicts between federal and state laws and establish a clear hierarchy.
Federalist 45:
Madison directly addresses the anxieties surrounding the potential threat of the federal government to state sovereignty. He argues that the "balance is much more likely to be disturbed by the preponderancy" of the states.
He cites historical examples of confederacies where the central government was weakened by the self-interested actions of member states, emphasizing that a strong Union is vital for the security and well-being of the American people.
Madison reiterates that the federal government's powers are "few and defined," primarily concerning external matters, while the states retain broad authority over "the lives, liberties, and properties of the people".
Federalist 46:
This paper delves into the relationship between the federal and state governments from the perspective of public opinion and support. Madison argues that the "first and most natural attachment of the people" will be to their state governments.
He contends that the federal government will need to demonstrate superior efficacy and responsiveness to gain greater public confidence.
Madison outlines the "disposition and the faculty" of each level of government to resist encroachments by the other, concluding that the states hold advantages due to their proximity to the people and their ability to mobilize public opinion.
Federalist 47:
This paper tackles the criticism that the Constitution violates the principle of separation of powers. Madison meticulously analyzes Montesquieu's writings and the constitutions of various states to demonstrate that complete separation is neither practical nor desirable.
He argues that Montesquieu's intent was to prevent the concentration of ALL power in any one branch, not to preclude any degree of shared functions or checks and balances between them.
Federalist 48:
Madison builds on the previous paper by asserting that a certain degree of "connection and blending" between the branches is necessary to prevent any one branch from becoming too dominant.
He argues that "parchment barriers" are insufficient to prevent power grabs, highlighting the historical tendency of legislatures to encroach on the executive and judicial branches.
Madison contends that the legislative department, due to its broad powers and control over finances, is the branch most likely to abuse its power.
Federalist 49:
This paper examines the proposition of using occasional constitutional conventions as a remedy for breaches of the separation of powers. While acknowledging the theoretical appeal of this approach, Hamilton (or Madison) raises several concerns.
He argues that frequent appeals to the people could undermine the stability and authority of the government by suggesting inherent flaws.
Hamilton (or Madison) also points out that conventions, being composed of individuals likely influenced by partisan allegiances, may not render impartial judgments on constitutional matters.
Federalist 50:
Building on the previous paper's arguments, this essay explores the idea of periodic appeals to the people as a way to enforce the Constitution. Hamilton (or Madison) finds this proposition equally problematic.
He argues that periodic reviews would either be too close to the events being reviewed, thus inheriting their biases, or too distant, making them ineffective in addressing current issues.
The paper concludes by highlighting the Pennsylvania Council of Censors as a failed example of periodic review, demonstrating the difficulty of achieving impartial and effective constitutional oversight through such a mechanism.
Key Quotes:
Federalist 41: "Security against foreign danger is one of the primitive objects of civil society. It is an avowed and essential object of the American Union."
Federalist 42: "The powers to make treaties and to send and receive ambassadors, speak their own propriety."
Federalist 43: "A power to destroy the freedom of the press, the trial by jury, or even to regulate the course of descents, or the forms of conveyances, must be very singularly expressed by the terms 'to raise money for the general welfare.'"
Federalist 44: "Bills of attainder, ex-post-facto laws, and laws impairing the obligation of contracts, are contrary to the first principles of the social compact, and to every principle of sound legislation."
Federalist 45: "The powers delegated by the proposed Constitution to the federal government are few and defined. Those which are to remain in the State governments are numerous and indefinite."
Federalist 46: "The federal and State governments are in fact but different agents and trustees of the people, constituted with different powers, and designed for different purposes."
Federalist 47: "The accumulation of all powers, legislative, executive, and judiciary, in the same hands, whether of one, a few, or many, and whether hereditary, self-appointed, or elective, may justly be pronounced the very definition of tyranny."
Federalist 48: "The legislative department is everywhere extending the sphere of its activity, and drawing all power into its impetuous vortex."
Federalist 49: "As the people are the only legitimate fountain of power, and it is from them that the constitutional charter, under which the several branches of government hold their power, is derived, it seems strictly consonant to the republican theory, to recur to the same original authority..."
Federalist 50: "If men exercise their reason coolly and freely on a variety of distinct questions, they inevitably fall into different opinions on some of them. When they are governed by a common passion, their opinions, if they are so to be called, will be the same."
This briefing document summarizes the key themes, ideas, and facts presented in Federalist Papers 41-50. It underscores the authors' efforts to justify the proposed federal government's powers, clarify its relationship with the states, and assuage concerns about potential tyranny. The provided quotes offer insights into the authors' reasoning and style of argumentation.
Share this post